Custom Catering, Just Like Mom Used to Make: Family Recipes for Your Next Event

When it comes to feeding a crowd, there’s nothing quite like homemade food - especially the kind that comes from decades-old family recipes. At Knuckle Sandwiches, we believe catering should feel personal, comforting, and delicious. That’s why we offer something special: custom catering that includes signature menu items plus the option to add dishes straight from our family cookbook.

Whether you're planning a corporate lunch, a family reunion, or a casual get-together, here’s how we bring heart, history, and unbeatable flavor to your next event.

Made to Order, From Our Family to Yours

Most catering companies offer a fixed menu. We’re not most catering companies.

While our standard menu is stacked with crowd-pleasers - think handcrafted sandwiches, fresh-baked bread, and bold sides - we go a step further. Our roots run deep in the kitchen, and we’ve carried down generations of recipes that never fail to bring people together.

Just tell us what you're dreaming of, and we’ll work with you to customize a menu that reflects your taste and ours.

A Few of Our Favorite Family Dishes

Here’s a peek into some of our most requested custom items:

• Slow-Roasted Italian Beef – Rich, tender, and perfect on a roll
• Grandma’s Meatball Subs – Made with hand-rolled beef and sweet marinara
• Classic Chicken Salad Sandwiches – With grapes, walnuts, and love in every bite
• Crispy Chicken Wings – Tossed in house-made sauces from sweet to spicy
• Fried Rice with a Twist – A family-style version packed with veggies and flavor
• Mini Sliders – Cheeseburger, BBQ pulled pork, or turkey & cranberry
• Red-Skin Potato Salad – A zesty upgrade to the classic
• Baked Mac & Cheese – Golden and bubbling with extra cheddar
• Deviled Eggs – Simple, creamy, and always the first to go
• Fruit Platters – Colorful, refreshing, and kid-approved
• Cheesecake Brownies – Fudgy, rich, and layered with tangy cream cheese

Every family has its staples - ours just happen to be really popular. We even offer a wide selection of breakfast items too, like burritos, bagels, and much more. YUMMY!

Customize Your Way

We know that no two events are the same. That’s why we work one-on-one with you to:

• Build a menu that fits your event theme, guest list, and dietary needs
• Offer flexible portions for small groups or large gatherings
• Set up sandwich bars, boxed meals, or full buffet spreads
• Accommodate gluten-free, vegetarian, or dairy-free requests
• Add in those “just like Mom’s” extras your guests will never forget

We even offer “Mix & Match Menus” that allow you to combine our signature items with family-style specialties.

Comfort Food, Professional Service

It’s one thing to serve up Grandma’s mac and cheese. It’s another to do it with warm smiles, attention to detail, and professional presentation.

From delivery and setup to cleanup and special requests, our catering team handles it all - so you can focus on your guests and enjoy the moment. No stress. No fuss. Just the comforting aroma of great food made with love.

Let’s Make It Personal

Have a specific dish in mind? Want to recreate a memory through food? We love that. Just give us a call, and let’s talk about how we can make your next event taste like home. Because at Knuckle Sandwiches, we don’t just cater meals - we cater memories.